There’s no better way to experience the flavor of a place than by tasting what it produces. In Ohio’s Amish Country, that means sampling handcrafted cheeses and locally made wines that reflect the land, traditions, and care behind every bite and sip. For guests of The Inn at Honey Run, exploring nearby Amish Country wineries and cheese shops offers an unforgettable culinary journey filled with artisan craftsmanship and rich, regional flavors. From creamy Swiss cheeses to award-winning fruit wines, this is a destination where quality and tradition come together in every product.
Discover the Cheese Culture of Amish Country
Amish Country is home to some of the finest cheese producers in the Midwest. Local dairy farms and family-owned businesses have been crafting cheese for generations using time-honored methods and high-quality ingredients. Many shops offer tastings, allowing guests to sample their way through a wide variety of cheeses—from sharp aged cheddars to smooth, mild Swiss and innovative blends with herbs and spices.
One must-visit stop is Heini’s Cheese Chalet in Millersburg. This iconic destination lets visitors sample dozens of cheeses made on-site. Popular options include yogurt cheese and flavored varieties like horseradish cheddar and smoked gouda. Guests can also watch the cheesemaking process through large viewing windows. Friendly staff are always ready to help you find your perfect match.
Another local favorite is Guggisberg Cheese, the birthplace of the original Baby Swiss. Located just outside of Charm, this shop produces smooth, creamy cheeses in small batches. Their Baby Swiss has won national awards and remains a guest favorite for its subtle nutty flavor and soft texture.
Troyer’s Country Market in Berlin is also worth a visit. With a wide selection of Amish-made cheeses, meats, and baked goods, it’s the perfect place to stock up on picnic essentials or bring home a taste of the region.
Raise a Glass at Amish Country Wineries
Pair your cheese with a locally crafted wine from one of the many Amish Country wineries and cheese shops dotting the countryside. The region’s rolling hills and temperate climate provide ideal growing conditions for grapes, especially for sweeter varieties and fruit-based wines.
A short drive from The Inn at Honey Run, Breitenbach Wine Cellars in Dover is a standout destination. Known for its award-winning fruit wines, this family-run winery offers tastings of favorites like dandelion, cherry, and blackberry. Guests can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere, beautiful patio views, and a gift shop filled with local products.
Another gem is Silver Moon Winery, a boutique winery in Dover that produces handcrafted wines ranging from dry reds to sweet whites. The tasting room is cozy and inviting, perfect for sampling new flavors and finding a bottle to enjoy back at the Inn.
Swiss Heritage Winery, located at Broad Run Cheesehouse, offers another fantastic stop. Guests can sip wine while browsing the cheese counter, making it easy to pair local cheeses with your favorite varietals. Their fruit wines are especially popular, and the knowledgeable staff can offer pairing suggestions for any palate.
Craft the Perfect Amish Country Pairing
One of the joys of exploring Amish Country wineries and cheese shops is creating your own perfect pairing. Pick up a wedge of Baby Swiss, a bottle of cherry wine, and a few locally made crackers for a simple yet satisfying evening snack. Enjoy it on your private patio at The Inn or pack a picnic to enjoy among the rolling hills.
The Inn at Honey Run also provides the ideal setting for a post-tour evening. After a day of culinary exploration, return to your cozy suite or cottage, relax by the fireplace, and savor your local finds in peace and comfort.
Plan Your Culinary Adventure
Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur, a wine enthusiast, or simply someone who loves to taste the local culture, exploring Amish Country wineries and cheese shops is a must during your stay at The Inn at Honey Run. The combination of rich flavors, warm hospitality, and scenic countryside makes every tasting a memorable part of your getaway.